The baseball world has lost a promising talent far too soon. Rob Mallicoat, a left-handed pitcher once considered a top prospect for the Houston Astros, passed away on October 19th in Yakima, Washington, at the age of 60, after a battle with colon cancer. While injuries ultimately curtailed his Major League career to just 53 games over three seasons (1987, 1991-92), his story is one of perseverance, dedication, and a love for the game that burned brightly. You can view his Baseball-Reference page here: [https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/malliro01.shtml?utmmedium=linker&utmsource=www.baseball-reference.com&utmcampaign=2025-11-28br]
Born Robbin Dale Mallicoat on November 16, 1964, in St. Helens, Oregon, his talent was evident from a young age. As a sophomore at Hermiston High School, he etched his name into the school's history books with a no-hitter on May 1, 1981, striking out an astounding 14 batters from Ontario High in a 4-0, 7-inning victory. That year, he set a school record with a remarkable 110 strikeouts! He and teammate Mark Keimig formed a dominant pitching duo, transforming Hermiston into a baseball powerhouse, culminating in an Intermountain Conference championship in 1982.
Later, Mallicoat transferred to Hillsboro High for his senior year, where he continued to impress, posting an incredible 0.85 ERA and racking up 118 strikeouts in 71 innings, despite a 2-5 record. His talent caught the eye of scouts, and he was drafted by the Detroit Tigers in the Eighth Round of the 1983 June Amateur Draft. But here's where it gets controversial... Mallicoat made a bold decision: he chose to attend Taft College in California instead. He believed in furthering his development before turning pro, a choice that ultimately led him to the Houston Astros, who selected him in the 1984 Secondary Phase Draft as the 16th overall pick in the First Round.
His decision paid off. In the spring of 1984, pitching for Taft, Mallicoat was virtually unhittable, boasting a perfect 7-0 record and a minuscule 1.71 ERA. He struck out 109 batters in just 79-1/3 innings, while allowing only 30 walks and 31 hits. This dominant performance earned him the title of 1984 Western State Conference Player of the Year, prompting him to finally embrace the professional ranks that summer.
"This has been my goal all through baseball," Mallicoat said upon signing with Houston in May 1984. "It’s going to be hard work, but I think it’s going to be a good experience." These words perfectly encapsulate his dedication and optimistic spirit.
Mallicoat's professional journey began with Class-A teams Asheville and Auburn, where he finished the year with a 3-4 record and a 4.02 ERA. His fastball and slider combination proved effective, generating 63 strikeouts in 69-1/3 innings, but his control needed refinement. Recognizing this, he dedicated himself to improvement, attending additional instruction camps in Florida and Arizona and even pitching in winter ball in Colombia. This commitment led to a phenomenal 1985 season with Osceola in the Florida State League, where he led the league with 16 wins, 159 strikeouts, and a stunning 1.37 ERA.
Mallicoat nearly skipped Triple-A altogether in 1986, with Houston manager Hal Lanier expressing his admiration during spring training. Lanier stated he didn't want to rush Mallicoat to the majors without giving him ample playing time in Triple-A. But then, disaster struck. A seemingly minor incident – stumbling in a sand trap while golfing – resulted in a severely sprained left ankle. This injury sidelined him for two months and led to eight consecutive losses without a win for Triple-A Tucson and Double-A Columbus before requiring season-ending surgery. It was a frustrating setback for a player on the cusp of realizing his dream.
A resilient Mallicoat bounced back in 1987, winning 10 games in the minors and earning a coveted call-up to the major leagues in September.
His MLB debut came on September 11, 1987, at Jack Murphy Stadium in San Diego. Entering the game in the bottom of the fifth inning with the Padres holding a comfortable 10-0 lead, Mallicoat showcased his potential, striking out two of the first three batters he faced. He allowed just one run – an RBI single to Chris Brown – in three innings of work. His second appearance, on September 16, saw him pitch two scoreless innings against San Francisco in another lopsided loss. However, his outing on the 19th against San Diego, facing just one batter in an extra-inning game, left him feeling unfulfilled. "I pitched well, but I ended up walking him [John Kruk]," Mallicoat told the East Oregonian. "Everybody was really happy with the way I was throwing, I just didn’t happen to get him out."
Mallicoat carried a 1.80 ERA into an October 2 start against Cincinnati, but the Reds proved to be a tough challenge. He was tagged for four runs on five hits in just 1-2/3 innings, leaving him with a 6.75 ERA, six walks, and four strikeouts in 6-2/3 innings.
Heading into spring training in 1988, Mallicoat was still regarded as a top Astros prospect and a strong contender for a left-handed relief role. However, fate intervened once again. He developed shoulder tendonitis, which was initially expected to delay his season, but ultimately wiped it out entirely. He spent the entire year in rehab. Further shoulder problems plagued him in 1989. And this is the part most people miss... After an initial surgery failed to resolve the issue, Mallicoat underwent a more extensive shoulder reconstruction surgery performed by Dr. Frank Jobe. It was a risky procedure, but it offered him the best chance to return to the mound. While his fastball velocity decreased from the 90s to the upper 80s, he compensated by refining his slider and adding a curveball to his repertoire. "I want to give it every chance I can to come back," he said that October. "If not, I would always feel I had cheated myself."
The Astros patiently nurtured Mallicoat's recovery. After pitching sparingly in the low minors in 1990, he showed enough promise to earn a promotion to the higher levels in 1991. His performance was inconsistent, but when the team needed a left-handed reliever that summer, Mallicoat received another chance in the majors after an absence of over three years.
Mallicoat's return occurred on August 17 against Los Angeles. After Darryl Strawberry walked and Eddie Murray doubled, Mallicoat struck out Juan Samuel before being replaced by Curt Schilling. The following day, he entered the game in the seventh inning with the Astros leading 6-4. He stranded two runners, striking out Strawberry and Gary Carter, and pitched scoreless eighth and ninth innings, earning his first major-league save in an 8-4 victory. With Al Osuna and Schilling sharing closing duties, Mallicoat became a setup man and a LOOGY (left-handed one-out guy). In 24 appearances for Houston in 1991, 13 were for an inning or less.
For the most part, Mallicoat performed well. Despite some struggles, including a grand slam allowed to Kevin Mitchell and a solo homer to Will Clark in a game against the San Francisco Giants on August 20, he finished the season with an 0-2 record and a 3.86 ERA. He struck out 18 batters and walked 13 in 23-1/3 innings, and those two home runs were the only ones he allowed. More importantly, he consistently pitched on short or no rest, proving that his shoulder could withstand the rigors of major-league pitching.
Mallicoat began the 1992 season in Triple-A Tucson but returned to Houston in May after seven consecutive scoreless appearances. He pitched brilliantly for the first month, posting a 2.25 ERA in his first 15 games. However, he struggled after that, allowing seven runs in 3-2/3 innings on June 14 and 15. He was sent back to Tucson at the end of June with a 5.96 ERA. After a September call-up, he allowed four runs in two appearances, raising his ERA to 7.23. In 23 games, Mallicoat also made two appearances as a pinch-runner, replacing Scott Servais in the ninth inning of a September 22 doubleheader nightcap against Cincinnati. He reached third base on a Casey Candaele double and scored on a Rafael Ramirez single, as a Houston rally fell just short in a 4-3 loss. This would be Mallicoat's final major-league appearance.
Diagnosed with a torn rotator cuff in March 1993, he underwent another surgery performed by Dr. Jobe. Another major surgery was widely considered career-ending, and Houston released Mallicoat in October.
In parts of three seasons, Mallicoat appeared in 53 games for Houston, 51 as a pitcher. He finished with an 0-2 record, a 5.70 ERA, and one save. In 53-2/3 innings, he allowed 56 hits and 38 walks while recording 42 strikeouts.
The shoulder surgery sidelined him in 1993, but it didn't mark the end of his baseball journey. He signed with the San Diego Padres and made two appearances for High-A Rancho Cucamonga in 1994, going 1-0 with a 3.38 ERA before leaving the team in April, dissatisfied with his performance. As he contemplated his next career move, the Kansas City Royals called him in the spring of 1995. "I think they just called to see if I was alive or not," he joked. The team was looking for replacement players due to the strike that had canceled the end of the 1994 season. "I’m just walking scar tissue," he quipped, but he pitched well for Kansas City in the spring, not allowing a run in his first 10 innings and securing a bullpen role until the strike was resolved.
Mallicoat pitched in three games for Triple-A Omaha before being released. He then played for an independent team in Corpus Christi and a team in China. But whatever magic he had discovered in spring training had faded, and the two reconstructive surgeries on his shoulder had taken their toll. Mallicoat retired at the age of 30. In nine seasons in the minor leagues, he had a 39-35 record and a 3.07 ERA, with 585 strikeouts.
After retiring from baseball, Mallicoat pursued a degree in computer science from Taft University. He then spent over 25 years in the IT world, working for Quest Software, Dell Technologies, and Microsoft. Per baseball writer Dan Good, who recently interviewed Mallicoat (https://www.dangoodstuff.com/p/remembering-rob-mallicoat), he is survived by three children and his partner, Tracy.
Rob Mallicoat's story is a reminder that success isn't always measured in statistics or accolades. It's about the journey, the dedication, and the resilience to overcome obstacles. He faced numerous setbacks, but he never gave up on his dream. His impact on those who knew him, both on and off the field, will be remembered for years to come.
For more information, you can read the Houston Chronicle's obituary: [https://www.houstonchronicle.com/sports/astros/article/rob-mallicoat-dead-obituary-pitching-prospect-21113701.php]
Follow me on Bluesky: @ripmlb [https://bsky.app/profile/ripmlb.bsky.social]
Discover more from RIP Baseball. Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
What are your thoughts on Mallicoat's decision to attend Taft College instead of immediately joining the Tigers organization? Do you think it ultimately helped or hindered his career? Share your opinions in the comments below.
